Skip to main content

Political Memoirs Are Very Odd Conceptually

A man wearing a gray suit jacket over a white shirt with minute red dots on it. He has a red and blue hankerchief in his breast pocket, and his right hand is holding his blue and gray patterned tie. He is wearing a very fancy-looking analog watch. Image is from https://www.pexels.com/photo/man-in-formal-suit-jacket-holding-his-necktie-1342609/.

Hello!

The topic that I initially wrote down for this blog post is "I Strongly Dislike Political Memoirs". However, between writing down this topic last night and drafting this blog post tonight, I have decided that a more accurate reflection of my opinion would be "Political Memoirs are a Very Strange Type of Book".

Let's consider a standard goals of a standard, everyday memoir written by a not-exactly-famous person. These goals would likely include:

  1. performing investigative journalism on one's own life.
  2. keeping the audience amused with engaging anecdotes.
In the case of a celebrity memoir, the author knows that the readers have expectations. They know who this celebrity is, and they likely know a thing or two about this celebrity's life already. As a result, part of writing a memoir as a celebrity is managing reader expectations and telling a (somewhat controlled) narrative of "how I got to be famous" while also telling stories about "what I was like before". 

And, essentially, a political memoir is a celebrity memoir that is fueled by a desire to get re-elected/get elected to a higher office/explain bad decisions made while in one's current office. I recently read Pete Buttigieg's Shortest Way Home and Julián Castro's An Unlikely Journey. While I cannot say that I entirely despised the process of reading either of these books, it's hard to feel engaged by a narrative when you know that it is in service of being elected as president. I want to be enchanted by your journey as a human being without knowing that this book is, at least in part, a way to make voters more likely to feel as though they know you and want to elect you to public office.

(As a side note, Amazon lists the author of An Unlikely Journey as "Bob Herbert" in my digital library, and, based on the content, it doesn't seem entirely implausible that this book was ghostwritten.)

Have you read any political memoirs lately? Do you like them? I have United by Cory Booker downloaded on my Kindle, and I'm wondering whether I should return it to my library in lieu of reading it. If you have read it, please let me know if it is worth reading!

Best wishes,
Lydia
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Grouchiest Blog Post

Hello! This post is literally just Grumpy Lydia complaining. If that sounds miserable, congratulations! You have my full permission to click away now. If that sounds like something you wouldn't mind reading, please enjoy and/or suffer through this list of Lydia's Miseries. I was on vacation in Italy all last week, which means that there are many lingering tasks that have not been completed. My flight was delayed on Monday, which means that I missed class, which has led to me being even more behind.  Housing selection was yesterday, and I am trying to force myself to come to terms with the fact that I'm pretty much definitely going to be living alone next year, which will contribute to my depression next year and makes me feel lonely in the present. There are just, like, a lot of lingering thoughts that I cannot find the words to write about.  It is cold and wet and sad outside, which means that a Self-Imposed Walk to Help With Lingering Sadness would probably jus...
Post a Comment
Read more

Reviewing My August 2019 Goals

This is an image of my desk during Fall Semester 2018. On the right side of the photo, there is a vintage Singer sewing machine which, unfortunately, does not work. To the left of the sewing machine, there is a crate books inside. On top of the crate, there is a stack of Rookie Yearbooks with a crocheted jellyfish (wearing glasses) on top of it, and a picture frame containing a print that reads "all the time". To the left of the crate, there are a few more books. In lieu of a proper bookend, I have placed a tarot deck (stored in a black makeup bag) and a book-themed Halloween decoration (featuring book spines with the words "Potions", "Hexes", and "Spells") to keep my books from toppling over. I chose this photograph because, unlike my current desk, this desk looks like it belongs to someone who creates monthly goals. Hello! At the start of this month, I made a list of goals. As September 1 draws near, I am l...
Post a Comment
Read more

Hourly Comics Day: 2018 and 2019

If you were to read through each of my old blog posts in order, you might notice a continuity error. In this blog post , I mentioned that I was participating in Hourly Comics Day, and that "my next blog post will be my completed comic". However, my next blog post was not, in fact, my completed comic; instead, it was my announcement that I had safely made it to Paris. This was the case for two main reasons: I vastly underestimated how busy I would be during my last day before traveling to Paris. I spent most of my last day before traveling for Paris frantically dealing with the disappearance of my debit card, only to discover that my debit card had been in my pocket all along. Today, I remembered this continuity error. I also recalled the Hourly Comics Day comic I did on February 1, 2018. I thought it might be interesting to post both comics, so that you can see how my life on February 1, 2018 compared to my life on February 1, 2019.  Since this post is very relia...
Post a Comment
Read more